
In 1967 when two characters by the name of Clyde Barrow and Bonnie Parker first appeared on movie theater screens, their presence would make a lasting impact on the forever changed American cinema. With its release, Arthur Penn’s
Bonnie and Clyde was an instant hit. Its gritty yet romanticized depiction of sex and violence won over both critics and fans and marked the beginning of an exuberant trend that would soon occur in the movies.
Bonnie and Clyde became one of the first motion pictures connected with and created under the New Hollywood era. Paving the way for the soon-to-arrive big Blockbuster pictures of the 1970s (
Jaws, Star Wars, Apocalypse Now), this new era of American filmmaking favored more studio control, bigger budgets, and less hindrance by censorship policies. The covers were finally ripped off in movies so to say. Movies from this era such as
The Graduate and
Blow-Up pioneered a trend of unrepressed sexuality while films like
Straw Dogs were packed tight with gut-wrenching violence. Penn managed to sustain both of these exotic themes in perfect balance with
Bonnie and Clyde and in the end managed to create a masterpiece that has yet to be forgotten. Innovative, striking and perverse all adequately describe this great movie and very deservingly,
Bonnie and Clyde will always be remembered as an American classic holding its place on the AFI’s
list of 100 Best American films.
But Bonnie and Clyde technically did not mark the movie debut of the two rambunctious bank robbers. Seventeen years prior to Penn’s movie, the couple appeared on screen under the names Annie Starr and Bart Tare in the 1950 film Gun Crazy directed by Joseph H. Lewis. Also taken from the real life account of Clyde Barrow and Bonnie Parker, Gun Crazy tells the same story of two impulsive, bank robbing lovers- and did it first. Though Gun Crazy was also a smash hit on its release and remains a critical acclaimed film (preserved in the National Film Registry), it is hard to say the original outshines its successor. Many people simply do not know the original 1950 film exists, while others simply prefer to pass on it in favor of the more modernized, sexualized and violent 1967 version.

Similarities aside,
Bonnie and Clyde and
Gun Crazy together represent the phenomenon of this singular story as constructed by two different eras of American filmmaking. Penn’s
Bonnie and Clyde had the freedom to blast their way through everyone and everything, showing it all too. His film includes one of the bloodiest death
scenes in cinematic history. But back in 1950, violence to the extent at which it is displayed to the audience in
Bonnie and Clyde was not tolerated by censorship regulations of the time. Lewis’ surrogate Bonnie and Clyde duo was forced to implement the same type of violent renegade characters only in a more repressed and subtle manner. These tightly-bound censorship policies manifest themselves in a particular scene from
Gun Crazy in which a long take is employed. Here, the differences between the old Classical Hollywood and the New Hollywood are on full display.